RUS | ENG | All
Enter the email or login, that you used for registration.
If you do not remember your password, simply leave this field blank and you will receive a new, along with a link to activate.

Not registered yet?
Welcome!

2019-11-06 12:50:00

UKRAINE NEED RUSSIA'S $12 BLN

UKRAINE NEED RUSSIA'S $12 BLN

PLATTS - With just eight weeks until the controversial gas agreement between Russia's Gazprom and Ukraine's Naftogaz expires, the legal quagmire surrounding the contract is becoming yet more complex.

Naftogaz has now filed a brand new claim to the Stockholm court of arbitration over the 10-year deal, seeking $12 billion in compensation from Gazprom for its refusal to accept market-based gas transit tariffs in 2018 and 2019.

The lawsuit was in response to Gazprom's own new claim from July this year seeking about $6 billion from Naftogaz for "unfair" transit contract obligations.

Given that Gazprom has said that it would not agree a new transit deal with Naftogaz unless the numerous legal cases between the parties are resolved, the stakes have never been higher given the risk of disruption to Russian gas flows via Ukraine to Europe from January 1.

Yuriy Vitrenko, the commercial director at Naftogaz who leads the company's legal team, said at the weekend the arbitration court was expected to rule on the Gazprom claim and Naftogaz counterclaim in 2021.

"In the new arbitration, we point out that there have been significant changes in the way transit tariffs are set since 2009," Vitrenko said.

"Our transit tariffs don't reflect the level of transit tariffs in the European market. It would be logical to set transit tariffs in line with modern European norms," he said, adding: "The tariff must reflect the real costs of the operator if these costs are in line with the costs of existing efficient operators."

ARBITRATION HISTORY

The latest arbitration tit-for-tat follows a ruling from the Stockholm court in February 2018 that found in favor of Naftogaz to the tune of some $2.56 billion across two cases -- one on supply and one on transit.

This could have marked the end of the dispute between the two companies over the agreement, which began in 2014, had the Russian side paid up.

However, Gazprom instead appealed the verdicts and then filed a separate request to have the agreement terminated completely.

Gazprom in August said hearings at the Svea court of appeal in Sweden against the main ruling in the supply case is set for February 2020, while its appeal in the transit case is scheduled for September-October 2020.

Its request for the entire agreement to be canceled will be heard only in April or May 2021.

There are also other appeal hearings set to be held in coming months around the case related to moves by Naftogaz to seize Gazprom assets in Europe in lieu of the $2.56 billion arbitration award.

Gazprom has offered to Naftogaz the chance to start over with a clean slate provided all legal disputes were dropped.

"There are known cases in international practice when disputes between companies were settled out of court, and we are offering a zero option whereby all court proceedings would cease, all lawsuits would be withdrawn, and we would draw a line under this whole affair," Miller said last month.

Naftogaz has repeatedly said, however, that it would not drop the arbitration case -- or others including efforts to enforce a $6.7 billion penalty imposed by Ukraine's anti-monopoly committee for Gazprom 's alleged abuse of its monopoly gas supply status.

LATEST CLAIM

Vitrenko said the $12 billion claim related to its demand for higher tariffs.

Complying with court procedures and schedule, Gazprom formally submitted its claims on July 14, 2019, which gave Naftogaz time to respond with its own counterclaims that have now been submitted to the same court.

"We are defending ourselves," Vitrenko said.

Naftogaz, he said, officially asked Gazprom on May 13, 2018 to change the gas transit tariffs to reflect market-based formulas used in Europe.

The claims for the new tariffs cover the period between March 13, 2018 and January 1, 2020, Vitrenko said.

Gazprom could not be reached for immediate comment Tuesday.

Vitrenko said the $12 billion claim reflected a difference of $11.8 billion between the new tariff level and what was paid by Gazprom.

He said Naftogaz was also claiming $200 million for Gazprom's failure to deliver 4 Bcm of gas in 2018 and 5 Bcm in 2019 (as stipulated in the February 2018 Stockholm court ruling) as it had had to buy more expensive gas in its place.

Naftogaz halted direct purchases of gas from Gazprom in November 2015 and has relied on its own production and European imports to meet demand.

-----


Earlier:

ТРАНЗИТ РУССКОГО ГАЗА
2019, October, 30, 10:15:00
ТРАНЗИТ РУССКОГО ГАЗА
“Мы констатировали, что все процессы запущены и идут по плану, но есть риски не успеть к началу 2020 года. Поэтому в качестве запасного варианта мы готовы обеспечить продление действующего договора по транзиту на 2020 год с изменением некоторых его условий”, - отметил Александр Новак.
РУССКИЙ ГАЗ ДЛЯ ЕВРОПЫ
2019, October, 30, 10:10:00
РУССКИЙ ГАЗ ДЛЯ ЕВРОПЫ
“Мы подчеркнули, что Россия готова работать по европейскому законодательству, если необходимо, готова работать и на базе существующего договора с корректировками”, - сказал Александр Новак.
UKRAINE NEED RUSSIA'S $12 BLN
2019, October, 30, 10:05:00
EUROPE NEED RUSSIA'S GAS
The current 10-year agreement between Gazprom and Naftogaz Ukrayiny expires at the end of 2019, and the EC is brokering talks aimed at putting a new contract in place to take effect from the start of 2020.
UKRAINE NEED RUSSIA'S $12 BLN
2019, October, 23, 12:30:00
RUSSIA, UKRAINE GAS DISPUTES
The current 10-year agreement between Gazprom and Naftogaz expires at the end of 2019, and the European Commission is brokering talks aimed at putting in place a new contract to take effect from the start of 2020.
All Publications »
Tags: UKRAINE, RUSSIA, GAS, GAZPROM, NAFTOGAZ
Chronicle:
UKRAINE NEED RUSSIA'S $12 BLN
2022, August, 9, 14:14:00
6TH ANNUAL LNG SUMMIT USA
The 6th Edition of Wisdom’s Much Acclaimed Annual LNG Summit Will Be Held Live in Houston - PREPARING THE INDUSTRY FOR THE RISE IN DEMAND FOR LNG
UKRAINE NEED RUSSIA'S $12 BLN
2022, August, 9, 14:13:00
2022 SAUDI PIPELINES INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE & EXIBITIONS
Eventat Co (a Saudi local company) is hosting the first-ever “2022 Saudi Pipelines International Conference & Exhibitions” from 4-6 October, 2022 at the Dhahran Expo, Dammam (Eastern Province), Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The three-day conference and exhibition are dedicated to bringing together over “50+ Regional/International speakers, 100+ Sponsors/Exhibitors, 1000+ Delegates and 3000+ Visitors” from around the globe who carry significant interest in enhancing the pipelines lifecycle for the current and future.
UKRAINE NEED RUSSIA'S $12 BLN
2022, August, 9, 14:12:00
9TH INTERNATIONAL LNG CONGRESS LNGCON 2023
9th International LNG Congress (LNGCON 2023) 6-7 March, 2023 Link to the Congress website: https://bit.ly/3tXVmr7
UKRAINE NEED RUSSIA'S $12 BLN
2022, August, 9, 14:10:00
RUSSIA FOR ITER FUSION
The 25th batch of Russian electrical equipment was successfully delivered to the construction site of the international thermonuclear experimental reactor Iter in France,
UKRAINE NEED RUSSIA'S $12 BLN
2022, August, 8, 12:50:00
OIL PRICE: BRENT ABOVE $94, WTI ABOVE $88
Brent were down 51 cents, or 0.5%, at $94.41 a barrel, WTI was at $88.58 a barrel, down 43 cents, or 0.5%.
UKRAINE NEED RUSSIA'S $12 BLN
2022, August, 8, 12:45:00
OPEC OIL PRICE: $100.01
The price of OPEC basket of thirteen crudes stood at $100.01 a barrel
UKRAINE NEED RUSSIA'S $12 BLN
2022, August, 8, 12:40:00
РАЗВИТИЕ ЭНЕРГЕТИКИ РОССИИ, ТУРЦИИ
Особое место в двустороннем взаимодействии занимает сфера энергетики: успешно функционируют газопроводы «Турецкий поток» и «Голубой поток», продолжается строительство первой турецкой АЭС «Аккую».
All Publications »