RUS | ENG | All
Enter the email or login, that you used for registration.
If you do not remember your password, simply leave this field blank and you will receive a new, along with a link to activate.

Not registered yet?
Welcome!

2020-10-02 10:55:00

CARBON, POWER PRICING

CARBON, POWER PRICING

PLATTS - 01 Oct 2020 - Carbon pricing could solve the "missing money" problem capacity markets were designed to address and, in doing so, eliminate the need for regulations the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has defended as necessary to mitigate the potential for price suppression from states' out-of-market resource procurement decisions, an economist said Sept. 30.

Power plant owners have complained for years about missing money, referring to lower revenues caused by policies and other factors that have driven energy and ancillary services prices down to levels that cannot sustain investment. With the launch of capacity markets, grid operators sought to make up for this missing money and ensure resource adequacy.

Recently, FERC has pushed market mechanisms that administratively raise the bids of resources receiving state subsidies on the Eastern regional transmission organizations operating mandatory capacity markets, as the commission's majority holds to its position that minimum offer price rules prevent capacity prices from dropping so low that capacity markets cease to ensure resource adequacy.

Double payment

The market rules have been criticized for lessening the likelihood that state-sponsored renewable resources will clear the capacity market, forcing consumers to pay for the subsidized generation as well as for a secondary fleet of resources able to clear the market and tick off reliability requirements that renewables are being precluded from counting toward.

"If carbon pricing allows those renewables to have enough revenue because the value of emissions will now be compensated in the energy markets, there is no longer a need for above-market contracts from the states," Matthew White, ISO New England's chief economist, said during a FERC technical conference on carbon pricing in wholesale markets.

He noted that some onshore wind facilities in New England are already economic and receive an offer floor of $0 under the region's MOPR rules.

"If that happens to all of the types of technologies the states seek to pursue, there is no longer a need for the MOPR; the energy market with carbon pricing has solved that problem," White asserted. "And the double payment that we hear much about in New England has been nicely solved in the course, by virtue of the carbon pricing."

Delving further into the logic of his assertions, White said that carbon pricing along with improvements to energy scarcity pricing could account for much of the so-called missing money for most generators. If the power sector heads in that direction through carbon pricing, "then there's no real reason to worry about price suppression in the capacity market because there's no missing money in the capacity market," he said.

Systemwide approaches

Mark Rothleder, California Independent System Operator's vice president of market policy and performance, added that carbon pricing could also aid the competitiveness of wholesale power markets.

"It provides a longer-term signal to the types of resources that you want to transition to and allows you to efficiently dispatch and invest in those resources that have the capabilities that you need," he said.

Challenges, however, could arise from a patchwork of different carbon programs across a regional footprint with little to no coordination. Different mechanisms and the interaction between those mechanisms could actually hinder competition, Rothleder contended.

Analysis by PJM Interconnection also pointed to benefits from a systemwide approach to carbon pricing as opposed to a few states trying to set an example with a high carbon price, Anthony Giacomoni, senior market strategist for advanced analytics at PJM, said.

"We found that even if you apply a $6/st carbon price across the entire PJM region, you get lower emissions and lower average prices for all regions, even those that don't have the carbon price applied, than if you applied a $25 price to just the eastern half of the PJM region," Giacomoni said.

"Individual states can take the lead on this, but if you look at what's most efficient for consumers, RTO-wide programs are by far the most cost-effective and effective at reducing emissions," he said.

Setting the price

Asked about the potential market repercussions of implementing a uniform carbon price across an RTO that is too low, White chimed in that such a scenario is the status quo.

He pointed to the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative in which all six New England states participate and that most recently cleared under $6/st.

While nothing would change if the carbon price remains too low, "it would be a lost opportunity."

White added that the move to a higher carbon price did not have to be immediate.

"Carbon pricing as a political reality doesn't have to be a big bang," he said. "One can certainly have a graduated system of carbon pricing that escalates over time, in a transparent way to facilitate investment, so that people can see the higher price of carbon going forward and make adjustments in time to account for it."

-----


Earlier:

CARBON, POWER PRICING
2020, September, 30, 13:05:00
GLOBAL NUCLEAR ENERGY UPDOWN
The World Nuclear Industry Status Report 2020 (WNISR2020) provides a comprehensive overview of nuclear power plant data, including information on age, operation, production, and construction of reactors.
CARBON, POWER PRICING
2020, September, 30, 12:55:00
RENEWABLE EMPLOYMENT UP TO 11.5 MLN
Employment in renewable energy worldwide was estimated at 11.5 million in 2019, up from 11 million in 2018. Women hold 32% of these jobs.
NUCLEAR POWER: CLEAN ENERGY TRANSITION
2020, September, 29, 12:50:00
NUCLEAR POWER: CLEAN ENERGY TRANSITION
A two-day Scientific Forum focused on ‘Nuclear Power and the Clean Energy Transition’. The Forum featured experts, government representatives and international organization representatives and academics, who spoke about how nuclear power can contribute to climate change goals and play a role in the clean energy transition.
CARBON, POWER PRICING
2020, September, 29, 12:45:00
ENVIRONMENTAL SIDE: $10 TLN
A powerful coalition of some 70 major financial institutions on five continents with total financial assets of more than $10 trillion has come over to the environmental side
CARBON, POWER PRICING
2020, September, 29, 12:40:00
NUCLEAR, HYDROGEN ENERGY
Nuclear has been left largely behind by booming demand for clean energy over the past decade.
CARBON, POWER PRICING
2020, September, 29, 12:35:00
GREEN HYDROGEN FOR EUROPE
Green hydrogen is beginning to have a main role in the energy strategies of many countries and companies. This molecule will have the capability of slowly displacing fossil fuels as a consequence of its versatility and gravimetric energy density.
CARBON, POWER PRICING
2020, September, 10, 14:25:00
CLEAN ENERGY TECHNOLOGIES: MUST USE
With global carbon emissions at unacceptably high levels, structural changes to the energy system are required to achieve the rapid and lasting decline in emissions called for by the world’s shared climate targets.
All Publications »
Tags: CARBON, POWER, ENERGY, ELECTRICITY, PRICE, CLIMATE
Chronicle:
CARBON, POWER PRICING
2021, July, 9, 12:04:00
HYDROGEN RUSSIA AND CIS, Moscow, 20-21 October 2021
International Conference and Exhibition ‘Hydrogen Russia and CIS’ brings together more than 200 senior executives of hydrogen production plants from Russia and the CIS
CARBON, POWER PRICING
2021, July, 9, 12:00:00
ARGENTINA'S NUCLEAR SMR
Before work was suspended, it was in line to be the world’s first operating SMR. The government licensed it as a prototype in 2009.
CARBON, POWER PRICING
2021, July, 9, 11:55:00
CHILE'S COAL GENERATION DOWN
In June 2021, the Chamber of Deputies of Chile has approved a bill that prohibits the installation and operation of coal-fired power plants.
CARBON, POWER PRICING
2021, July, 8, 12:50:00
OIL PRICE: NEAR $73
Brent slipped by 23 cents, or 0.3%, to $73.20 a barrel, WTI were down 33 cents, or 0.5%, at $71.87 a barrel.
CARBON, POWER PRICING
2021, July, 8, 12:45:00
OIL PRICES 2021-22: $72-$67
We expect rising production will reduce the persistent global oil inventory draws that have occurred for much of the past year and keep prices similar to current levels, averaging $72/b during the second half of 2021 (2H21).
CARBON, POWER PRICING
2021, July, 8, 12:40:00
EUROPE CLIMATE RULES
According to draft proposals seen by market sources, the CBAM will replace the current system of free carbon allowances for metals sectors, and tighten allowances in the European Emissions Trading System generally, a bone of contention for some.
CARBON, POWER PRICING
2021, July, 8, 12:35:00
ASIA INDEXES DOWN ANEW
The Hang Seng index (.HSI) led losses with a 1.9% drop, its eighth consecutive session in the red, with more falls in internet giants Tencent (0700.HK), Meituan (3690.HK) and Alibaba (9988.HK) as the sector reels from sweeping Chinese regulatory scrutinty.
All Publications »