RUS | ENG | All
Enter the email or login, that you used for registration.
If you do not remember your password, simply leave this field blank and you will receive a new, along with a link to activate.

Not registered yet?
Welcome!

2022-01-10 11:25:00

RENEWABLES COULD NOT REPLACE

RENEWABLES COULD NOT REPLACE

 

By EDWARD REID, JR. Vice President, Marketing (Retired) / Executive Director (Retired) / President (Retired) Columbia Gas Distribution Companies / American Gas Cooling Center / Fire to Ice, Inc. 

ENERGYCENTRAL - Dec 28, 2021 -  Calendar year 2021 has provided numerous important lessons regarding climate change and efforts to control or eliminate it.

The most fundamental and important lesson is that weather is not climate, which is essentially the average of weather over a 30-year period. Weather varies significantly from the average which is climate on an hourly, daily, weekly, monthly, seasonal and annual basis. Energy systems must be designed to function efficiently and effectively over the expected range of weather variability.

Perhaps the starkest example of this distinction was the “wind drought’ which occurred in the UK and parts of Europe this fall, resulting in 10+ days of little or no wind and solar renewable generation, well below the average for the current climate. This event made clear that renewable generation could not replace conventional fossil and nuclear generation when there was low/no wind and solar. Rather, renewable generation is redundant generation, additional capacity which is useful when available but requires full capacity backup when it is not available. The installation of redundant generation increases utility investment and cost, which is then reflected in customer rates.

However, the effects of the “wind drought” were exacerbated by the closing of numerous fossil and nuclear generating facilities and a fire in an underwater power cable between France and the UK, reducing available backup generation to very dangerous levels. There is limited data available on the frequency and duration of “wind droughts” or periods of much lower-than-average solar availability.

Similar lesson was learned in Texas, which experienced a solar vortex driven cold event, resulting in severely reduced wind generation. In this event, the essential backup generators were not prepared to handle the load, largely because of the reluctance of the utilities to pay the generators to be available. The lesson here is that while the wind might “blow all the time”, except when it doesn’t, it cannot be relied upon and dispatched as required. While it has long been utility practice to maintain a 20% capacity reserve margin for periods when some generators are offline for maintenance or repairs, in systems with renewable generation the capacity reserve margin must equal the renewable generation percentage plus the typical capacity reserve margin.

These events have made it painfully obvious that renewable generators must be matched with storage capacity sufficient to render them dispatchable under all expected operating conditions to replace conventional, dispatchable generation in reliable electric grids. The extent of the storage required is a function of weather variability and seasonal variability in wind and solar availability. Accurately assessing the required storage capacity becomes progressively more important as the grid reliance on intermittent generation sources increases.

Another lesson of 2021 is that natural variability has not ceased to influence both weather and climate. Calendar year 2021 is the sixth year of a second “hiatus” in global average temperature anomaly increases, despite continued increases in atmospheric GHG concentrations.

The final lesson of 2021, as demonstrated at COP26, is that developing nations consider their economic development to be of far greater concern than climate change.

-----

This thought leadership article was originally shared with Energy Central's Energy Collective Group. The communities are a place where professionals in the power industry can share, learn and connect in a collaborative environment. Join the Energy Collective Group today and learn from others who work in the industry.

-----


Earlier:

RENEWABLES COULD NOT REPLACE
2021, December, 20, 12:20:00
GLOBAL CLIMATE POINTS: 50,000 YEARS
The important message is that the earth has experienced a major tipping point approximately every 50,000 years.
RENEWABLES COULD NOT REPLACE
2021, December, 20, 12:15:00
GLOBAL ENERGY WORKFORCE CHANGES
In the energy industry, a survey revealed that almost half, that is 43 percent of workers worldwide are considering leaving the energy industry within the next five years.
RENEWABLES COULD NOT REPLACE
2021, December, 17, 12:30:00
NUCLEAR CLIMATE PROTECTION
Egypt is the second largest economy in Africa and its electricity production is heavily reliant on oil and gas. Mr El-Sisi thanked Mr Grossi for the support the IAEA has given Egypt in its nuclear programme.
RENEWABLES COULD NOT REPLACE
2021, December, 16, 14:35:00
NUCLEAR POWER IS A KEY
The United Arab Emirates (UAE) is a global pioneer in innovation and a regional leader in using nuclear energy to meet its sustainable energy and climate action ambitions
RENEWABLES COULD NOT REPLACE
2021, December, 15, 13:15:00
GLOBAL RENEWABLES WILL UP TO 4,800 GW
Globally, renewable electricity capacity is forecast to increase by over 60% between 2020 and 2026, reaching more than 4 800 GW.
RENEWABLES COULD NOT REPLACE
2021, November, 17, 13:50:00
GLOBAL ENERGY DEMAND WILL UP BY 28%
Global energy demand is set to increase from 275.4 mboe/d in 2020 to 352 mboe/d by 2045
RENEWABLES COULD NOT REPLACE
2021, October, 11, 11:50:00
GLOBAL ENERGY CONSUMPTION WILL UP BY 50%
Global energy consumption will increase nearly 50% over the next 30 years.
All Publications »
Tags: RENEWABLE, CLIMATE