RUS | ENG | All
Enter the email or login, that you used for registration.
If you do not remember your password, simply leave this field blank and you will receive a new, along with a link to activate.

Not registered yet?
Welcome!

2022-12-05 11:30:00

FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION

FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION

 

By DOUG HOUSEMAN  Visionary and innovator in the utility industry and grid modernization Burns & McDonnell

ENERGYCENTRAL - Nov 29, 2022 - Many things about the energy transition are foolish and driven not by science, but by feelings or politics.

One of those is the public fight that occurs between supporters of various technology. Solar vs. wind vs. nuclear vs. anything else. The reality is we need them all.

Many of the people pushing on technology over others make their living from that technology, so bashing the others seems like a good idea, but it is not.

When you bash one technology, that one bashes back – resulting in all sorts of rumors, and issues that non-believers use as evidence that none of them work or are worth the investment. These are largely the uninvolved people, and there are more uninvolved than involved. They vote too, bash enough and their votes will go to candidates who don’t believe.

Then there are the people who push to tear down power plants, rather than mothballing them for emergencies and paying a small stand by fee for occasions like Polar Vortex events.

Having them in cold standby with fuel at hand means they can be brought online and used in events like we saw in Texas in 2021. That event did more to undermine the transition than any other in the eyes of the uninvolved. Keeping the power on and reliable is critical to getting support for the transition.

Winter night, the bane of sunlight loving solar, will become the peak electric load when natural gas and other fossil fuels disappear.

Having back up plans for a polar vortex that include generation of more energy will be crucial. (Demand response will be addressed).

Government needs to stop picking winners and losers. Instead, they should set goals, and support anything that can meet or beat that SET of goals. No GHG is nice but having it as a firm schedulable resource is also a goal that needs support.

Massive unlimited subsidies that are specific to technologies and lock out other technology, disadvantages those locked out. That means that promising new technologies may never become real (e.g. Fusion) because they will always fight a cost disadvantage.

Don't assume that a supplier will always be willing to sell product to you. Global alignments and goals change. If the technologies we are installing for the transition are critical infrastructure, then they need to be treated that way, and an independent supply chain needs to be established.

Otherwise we could all be facing what Germany is with Russian gas, because like gas, with the flow of lithium, wind turbines, or solar panels (or major components) shut off at a future date.

Oh, and don't promise that fossil fuels will disappear by date "X", it only scares people who are worried about heat, lights and getting to work. Work instead on creating a world where they just stop being used because other choices are cheaper and easier.

For the uninvolved right now that seems scary and impossible. So far no transition technology has lived up to its initial hype.

-----

This thought leadership article was originally shared with Energy Central's Energy Collective Group. The communities are a place where professionals in the power industry can share, learn and connect in a collaborative environment. Join the Energy Collective Group today and learn from others who work in the industry.

-----


Earlier:

FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2022, November, 21, 10:50:00
GLOBAL ENERGY TRANSITION DOESN'T WORK
Comparing a Solar Variable Renewable Energy Farm to an On-Demand Base Load Coal Fired Power Station is like saying you can use tomato sauce to replace vegetables.
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2022, November, 1, 17:10:00
GLOBAL ENERGY DEMAND WILL UP BY 23%
Global primary energy demand is forecast to continue growing in the medium- and long-term, increasing by a significant 23% in the period to 2045. The world needs to annually add on average 2.7 million barrels of oil equivalent a day to 2045.
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2022, October, 25, 14:50:00
GLOBAL ENERGY SECURITY
China's crude imports from Russia have continued to stay elevated through 2022, averaging at 1.71 million b/d over January-August, up 7.3% year on year, according to customs data.
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2022, October, 25, 14:45:00
GLOBAL ENERGY RESILIENCE
Lesson one is that energy security and energy transition must be in balance to sustain energy systems that are also affordable.
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2022, October, 17, 12:25:00
GLOBAL CLEAN ENERGY: SLOWLY AND EXPENSIVE
Progress on the world’s rising climate action ambitions could be undermined by a shortage of some of the critical minerals used in clean-energy technologies including wind turbines, solar farms and electric vehicles (EVs),
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2022, October, 10, 12:40:00
GLOBAL CLIMATE WITHOUT CRISIS
The nations which are home to more than half of the world’s population are not treating climate change as a crisis.
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2022, October, 3, 12:00:00
GLOBAL 3D ENERGY TRANSITION
Today, the 3Ds of energy: Decarbonization, Decentralization and Digitalization, are driving the energy transition and the new energy sources and market participants that go along with it.
All Publications »
Tags: ENERGY, ENERGY TRANSITION, CLIMATE
Chronicle:
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2023, February, 3, 11:29:00
9TH INTERNATIONAL LNG CONGRESS LNGCON 2023
9th International LNG Congress (LNGCON 2023) 6-7 March, 2023 Link to the Congress website: https://bit.ly/3tXVmr7
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2023, February, 3, 11:28:00
TRANSPORTATION OIL AND GAS CONGRESS 2023 (TOGC 2023)
Transportation Oil and Gas Congress 2023 (TOGC 2023) takes place on February 20-21, 2023. The Congress brings together representatives from the whole pipeline chain and focuses on both strategic and technical issues of the oil and gas pipeline transportation.
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2023, February, 3, 11:25:00
ЦЕНА URALS: $49.48
Средняя цена на нефть марки Urals в январе 2023 года сложилась в размере $49,48 за баррель, что в 1,7 раз ниже, чем в январе 2022 года ($85,64 за баррель).
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2023, February, 3, 11:20:00
RUSSIAN GAS TO EUROPE DOWN AGAIN
Total Russian pipeline exports to Europe in January via the two remaining major supply routes were 36% down on deliveries in December and 79% lower year on year.
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2023, February, 3, 11:15:00
BP: THE TRANSITION TO A LOW-CARBON WORLD
The transition to a low-carbon world requires a range of other energy sources and technologies, including low-carbon hydrogen, modern bioenergy, and carbon capture, use and storage.
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2023, February, 3, 11:10:00
GERMAN WIND ENERGY 7 GW
Germany targets 30 GW of offshore wind by 2030. The country had 7.7 GW of offshore wind installed capacity at the end of 2021.
FOOLISH ENERGY TRANSITION
2023, February, 3, 11:05:00
INDIA GREEN TRANSITION $8 BLN
India plans to spend US$4.3bn on energy transition through the Ministry of Petroleum and Gas, including programs for green fuel, green energy, green farming, green mobility, green buildings, and green equipment and policies for efficient use of energy across various economic sectors.
All Publications »